Sefaria Kitzur Shulchan Arukh 9, trans. Rabbi Avrohom Davis, Metsudah Pub., 1996
Sefaria Kitzur Shulchan Arukh 9, trans. Rabbi Avrohom Davis, Metsudah Pub., 1996
Current Version
Current Translation
Among the laws the Sages learned from this verse are:
1) "תַּעֲשֶׂה" —the tzitzis must be "made" i. e. the attaching of the tzitzis is the final act which makes the garment fit for the fulfillment of the mitzvah. If, however, after attaching the tzitzis there is something else to be done to complete the mitzvah then it is invalid because the tzitzis were not "made" but came into being. We call this "תַּעֲשֶׂה וְלאׁ מִן הֶעָשׂוּי" —"make" and not that which came into being by itself (v. para. 6).
2) "עַל אַרְבַּע כַּנְפוֹת" —"on the four corners" —The mitzvah is to attach the tzitzis at the "corners." It is considered the corner [when it is] no more than three thumb breadths (agudlin) and not less than the distance between the thumb's middle knuckle to the end of the nail from the edge of the garment.
The hole through which the tzitzah is inserted should be no further than three thumb-breadths from the edge of the garment, whether along its length or width. (Some maintain that these thumbs are measured at the narrow part of the thumb, that is, at its tip, and it is proper to follow this stricter [opinion] see Sha'arei Teshuva), because if it is more than three thumb-breadths [away] it is not considered the corner of the garment but [rather] the garment itself. If the hole was made above three thumb-breadths, although upon tying the tzitzah and drawing the knot, the garment is creased causing the hole to be lowered, it is nevertheless invalid. If, after threading the tzitzah through the hole which is above the prescribed distance, he widened the hole by cutting it in order that the tzitzah hangs within three thumb-breadths [of the edge], it is [still] invalid because Scripture states: "You shall make," and not [that] which is already made. Likewise, the hole should not be closer to the garment edge, whether along its length or width, than the distance from the middle knuckle of the thumb to the end of the thumb nail, because less than this amount is also not considered the corner but rather under the corner. If the hole was the proper distance [from the edge] but by pulling the knot the garment edge shrank so that there is no longer the proper distance, it is nevertheless valid. If there are fringes on the garment edge and they are not woven into the garment, it is questionable if they are included as part of these measurements or not. Therefore, it is necessary to cut them before attaching the tzitzis. Regarding the small tallis, some people have the custom to make two holes next to each other similar to the vowel tzeirei, and they thread the tzitzis through both holes so that they hang on the garment towards the outside.
Some go so far as to say that even where the owner explicitly objects, use may be made of his tallis. (Responsa Maharsham Vol. I 29) Others, however, maintain that if the owner is known to be one who would usually object then it is not permitted to use the article without specific permission (Mishnah Berurah 14: 13). Still others go even further and hold that nowadays everyone is assumed to mind and specific permission must be received (Aruch Hashulchan 14: 11).
It is permissible to borrow someone's tallis on an irregular basis, even without his knowledge, and use it for prayers and to recite a berachah over it, because it may be assumed that one is pleased that a mitzvah is performed with his property, if it is at no loss to [the owner]. However, [the article] may not be removed from the house in which it was placed because the owner may object to that. If the [borrower found] the tallis folded he should replace it folded, but on Shabbos he may not fold it [and it may be assumed] that since the reason for his not folding it is due to a Shabbos restriction, the owner would not object. One who borrows a tallis from another only for the purpose of going up to [read from] the Torah, there is a halachic question if the berachah is recited. Therefore, you should specifically intend not to acquire the tallis, thereby, according to all opinions, you are not required to recite a berachah. However, on the congregation's tallis, even if you take it only for going up to the Torah, you are required to recite a berachah, because it is considered as if it were yours.
A large tallis with a seam down the middle whose tzitzis are validly attached is separated at the seam for the purpose of facilitating the handling of the tallis during laundering or mending. We, thus, have "two" taleisim (the Yiddish plural of tallis) with two tzitzis each. We are now faced with a problem—sewing the two halves together again would result in validating the tallis for the mitzvah through an act not done directly to the tzitzis. Thus: Ta'aseh velo min he'asui. The author here proposes a solution to the problem.
This paragraph deals with a tallis that had tzitzis [attached] and was divided into two [halves] as is common with many of our taleisim, that are sewn together from separate sections. Occasionally [the sections] are separated in order to launder it, or to mend it, and then is restitched. Since there is usually enough left in each section to enwrap a person, it is sufficient to remove two of the tzitzis from any section and after restitching the tallis to retie the tzitzis. However, if each section is not large enough to enwrap a person, he must [first] remove all of the tzitzis (because when the sections were separated each part is exempt from the mitzvah of tzitzis, and when they are later reattached and require tzitzis, then, if the original tzitzis remain the tallis is invalid because of Ta'aseh velo min he'asui as [was mentioned] previously in paragraph six). If in one section there is a sufficient amount [left] to enwrap [a person], and in the other section there is not enough to enwrap [a person], he should [then] remove the tzitzis from the part that does not have enough to enwrap a person.
Some authorities hold: that on the entire area of the corner, which is eligible for attaching the tzitzis, that is, from after the length of the first thumb knuckle, from the edge of the tallis until a length of three thumb-breadths, there should not be any stitches whatsoever with a thread that may be used in the making of tzitzis for this particular tallis; for example, if the tallis, was made of linen, one should not sew there with linen threads, but [use] only silk threads or the like. [Likewise] if the tallis is silk it should not be sewn with silk threads. If the tallis was made of wool it should not be sewn with woolen threads but with silken threads or the like. It is preferable to adhere to this strict view also in regard to the hem that is made around the hole to reinforce it (the hole). All of the above, however, applies only to white thread but with colored threadthere is no reason for concern.
If you go to a Synagogue on Shabbos and discover that a tzitzah of your tallis has become invalid and you are unable to borrow another tallis and you are embarrassed to sit without a tallis, then, since it is not possible for you to tie another tzitzah on this day, therefore for the sake of your dignity you are permitted to wear the tallis as is but you should not recite the berachah. This is applicable only if you were unaware before Shabbos that [the tzitzah] became invalid, but if you knew before Shabbos that it became invalid you are forbidden to wear the tallis, since you should have fixed it the day before.
A Living Library of Torah
Sefaria is home to 3,000 years of Jewish texts. We are a non-profit organization offering free access to texts, translations, and commentaries so that everyone can participate in the ongoing process of studying, interpreting, and creating Torah. Learn More ›Ariel your Representee, | אריאל הנציג שלך, נציג אפרים ויועץ (לא רב אלא יועץ ידידותי) של בית ישראל הבינלאומי בהר הבית ולכל עם ישראל. נולדתי בהולנד והפכתי בגיל מאוחר יותר לבעל תשובה: במקור, המונח התייחס ליהודי שעבר על ההלכה ביודעין או שלא ביודעין והשלים תהליך של התבוננות פנימית כדי "לחזור" לקיום המצוות המלא. של מצוות אלוהים. לקרוא |
Comments
Post a Comment